Comparison

ProperLease vs paper and a filing cabinet

Paper has kept landlords honest for a century. What it cannot do is answer a question quickly, exist in two places at once, or survive a flood in the basement it is stored in.

Start free with one property One property free, forever. Keep the cabinet if you want to.
0backups a filing cabinet keeps of itself
1place the only signed copy exists
48provinces and states whose lease document ProperLease produces, filled and ready to sign

Plenty of experienced owners still run on paper: a signed lease in a folder, rent receipts in a shoebox, a chequebook stub as the payment record. It is not a foolish system. It is a system with one hard limit, which is retrieval.

The cost of paper is not that it fails. It is that it only fails at the moment you need it, when a tenant disputes a deduction, when a tribunal asks for the dated notice, or when your accountant wants last year's repairs and you have twelve months of receipts in no particular order.

Where ProperLease wins

The honest case for choosing ProperLease over paper.

Everything is searchable, instantly

What did this tenant pay in March, how much deposit is held, when did the term start. On paper each of those is a trip to the cabinet. In ProperLease they are on the tenant's record, already answered.

It exists in more than one place

Fire, flood, a move, a misfiled folder. A paper archive has a single point of failure and no copy. Records kept in ProperLease are backed up and reachable from your phone while you are standing in the unit.

Photos attach to the tenancy, not to a drawer

Move-in and move-out condition reports hold their photographs against the tenancy they belong to, so the comparison at move-out is a side by side rather than a memory.

The year-end summary already exists

Expenses categorised per property as they happen come out as a report lined up to the T776 or Schedule E. Adding up a shoebox in February is not a system, it is an annual penance.

Where paper is the better choice

A comparison you can trust has to be able to say this part out loud. Here is where they genuinely win.

A wet-ink signature is hard to argue with

A signed original lease, initialled on every page, is about as robust as evidence gets. Keep signing on paper if you want to. Scan the signed copy into the document vault afterwards and you have both.

No account, no password, no dependency

Paper does not need a subscription, an internet connection, or a company that still exists in ten years. For an owner who distrusts all of that, it is a coherent position rather than a stubborn one.

Some tenants genuinely prefer it

A handwritten receipt and a folder of paperwork is what some tenancies have always run on, and forcing a change is not always worth the friction. Digital records on your side do not require your tenant to change anything.

Side by side

ProperLease against paper, feature by feature.

 ProperLeasepaper
Leases and documents
Province and state lease documentsFills the official government form in Ontario, British Columbia and Quebec. Generates a residential lease carrying the required disclosures in 45 US states.You download the form, print it, and fill it in by hand. The version you print is current only if you checked.
Late rent and eviction noticesPlain-English notice templates filled from the tenancy record, emailed, and logged with the date they went out. They are our own wording, not the tribunal's official form.Handwritten or typed each time, and only correct if the template you kept is still the right one.
Move-in and move-out condition reportsBuilt in, photo backed, attached to the tenancy so move-out compares against move-in.A printed checklist and photos that live somewhere else. Nothing links the two.
Documents stored against the tenancyDocuments attach to the tenant and the lease: the signed lease, ID, insurance, the move-in inspection. They sit on the record they belong to, not in a folder.The cabinet. Excellent until you are not standing next to it.
Rent and money
Dated rent ledger per tenantEvery payment is a permanent dated entry. Nothing is overwritten, so the history survives.A receipt book is a genuine append-only ledger, which is more than a spreadsheet can say. Reading it back is the slow part.
Late rent surfaced without you lookingExpected rent is compared to what arrived. Anything short or missing is flagged on the dashboard and in your inbox.You work it out by flipping through. Nothing tells you.
Deposits tracked as money you owe backHeld separately from rent, so the balance you owe at move-out is never guesswork.A figure on the lease and a memory of what was deducted. Move-out is where this hurts.
Expenses tracked per propertyCategorised per property and unit, with receipts attached, as you spend rather than in April.A box of receipts, faithfully kept and entirely unsummarised.
Tax and reporting
Year-end reports built for the T776 and Schedule EOne export per property, with the categories already lined up to the form your accountant is filling in.Built by hand, each year, from the box.
Real cashflow per propertyRent in, expenses out, per door, so you can see which property is actually earning.Only after the annual reckoning, which means you learn it eleven months late.
Dated record of what you sentEvery notice and reminder ProperLease sends is logged with the recipient, the date and the time. A resend adds an entry rather than replacing one.Good, if you kept copies and dated them. Nobody keeps copies of everything.
Cost and effort
How it is pricedone property free, forever. Premium is $14.99 CAD a month or $99 CAD a year for the whole portfolio. No per-door charge, no per-document fee.Paper, ink and a cabinet. Cheap in money, expensive in hours.
Time to get runningAn evening. Add a property, add a tenant, import your payment history from CSV.None. That is the appeal.
Works from your phoneA native iPhone app. Mark rent paid, photograph a receipt, start a condition report from the doorway.No. The records are where the cabinet is.

This comparison reflects publicly available information as of September 21, 2026, plus our own reading of how these approaches work in practice. Products and prices change, and we do not publish other vendors' prices here. Check the vendor's own site before you decide. If you think something on this page is wrong, tell us and we will fix it.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to stop keeping paper copies?

No, and we would not suggest it. Sign on paper if you prefer, keep the original in the cabinet, and scan it into the document vault so there is a second copy that you can search and reach from anywhere.

How do I get years of existing paper into ProperLease?

Do not try to backfill everything. Start with what is live: current tenants, current leases, deposits held, and this year's expenses. Scan older documents only when you actually need them. Most owners are running properly within an evening.

Is a digital lease legally valid?

In most Canadian provinces and US states a lease can be signed electronically, but the rules and the exceptions vary, and some jurisdictions treat particular documents differently. This is general information rather than legal advice. Check the requirements where your property is, and when in doubt print the generated lease and sign it in ink.

What happens to my records if I stop paying?

You can export your data, and the free tier keeps one property free, forever. The point of a document vault is that you are not trapped in it.

What does ProperLease cost?

One property free, forever, then Premium at $14.99 CAD a month or $99 CAD a year for the whole portfolio. There is no per-door charge and no per-document fee for the leases and notices it produces.

Run your rentals with absolute clarity

ProperLease helps self-managing landlords in Canada and the US track rent, generate provincial and state leases, serve notices, and stay tax ready.